Experimental Comparisons Between Modular Multilevel DSCC Inverters and TSBC Converters for Medium-Voltage Motor Drives

This paper makes an intensive comparison in operating performance between a modular multilevel double-star chopper-cells (DSCC) inverter and a modular multilevel triple-star bridge-cells (TSBC) converter. Both inverter and converter are intended to drive medium-voltage motors in industrial applications. First, it makes numerical comparisons, thus, resulting in revealing that the torque and frequency of a driven motor produce a significant effect on capacitor-voltage fluctuation and arm or cluster current in the individual DSCC inverter and TSBC converter. Next, a three-phase DSCC inverter and a three-phase TSBC converter with the same rating as 400 V and 15 kW are designed and compared to drive the following two general purposes and specially-designed induction motors; one is rated at the 380-V, 15-kW, 50-Hz four-pole motor, and the other is at the 320-V, 15-kW, 38-Hz six-pole motor. This experimental comparison based on the two downscaled drive systems confirms the validity of the numerical comparison. Finally, this paper concludes that the DSCC inverter is more suitable for driving medium-voltage high-speed motors loaded with quadratic-torque-to-speed profiles like fans, blowers, pumps, and centrifugal compressors. On the other hand, the TSBC converter is more suitable for driving medium-voltage low-speed high-torque motors like mills, kilns, conveyors, and extruders.