Residual Density Effects on Growth and Thinning Productivity in Naturally Regenerated Pinus densiflora Stands

Natural forest regeneration offers economic, ecological, and environmental advantages over artificial regeneration; however, its application is often constrained by uncertainties in stand development and management outcomes. Pre-commercial thinning (PCT), a key assisted natural regeneration practice, is widely used to regulate stand density and improve early stand development. Nevertheless, empirical evidence remains limited regarding how post-thinning residual density influences both tree growth and operational performance in high-density naturally regenerated Pinus densiflora stands. This study evaluated three residual density treatments (RD2000, RD3000, and RD5000) following PCT in naturally regenerated pine stands with an initial density of approximately 30,000 stems ha−1. Diameter at breast height, tree height, and crown area were monitored annually over three years, while thinning productivity and operational costs were quantified during treatment implementation. Residual density significantly affected both biological and operational outcomes. The intermediate residual density (RD3000) showed the most consistent growth responses, whereas the lowest residual density (RD2000) resulted in suppressed growth. The highest residual density (RD5000) achieved the highest productivity and lowest operational costs despite moderate growth performance. These results indicate a trade-off between growth performance and operational efficiency and suggest that an intermediate residual density may provide a balanced strategy for managing naturally regenerated pine stands.