Peer Review #2 of "Dinosaur origin of egg color: oviraptors laid blue-green eggs (v0.1)"

Protoporphyrin (PP) and biliverdin (BV), give rise to the enormous diversity in avian egg coloration.Egg color serves several ecological purposes, including post-mating signaling and camouflage.Egg camouflage represents a major character of open-nesting birds which accomplish protection of their unhatched offspring against visually oriented predators by cryptic egg coloration.Cryptic coloration evolved to match the predominant shades of color found in the nesting environment.Such a selection pressure for the evolution of colored or cryptic eggs should be present in all open nesting birds and relatives.Many birds are open-nesting, but protect their eggs by continuous brooding, and thus exhibit no or minimal eggshell pigmentation.Their closest extant relatives, crocodiles, protect their eggs by burial and have unpigmented eggs.This phylogenetic pattern led to the assumption that colored eggs evolved within crown birds.The mosaic evolution of supposedly avian traits in non-avian theropod dinosaurs, however, such as the supposed evolution of partially open nesting behavior in oviraptorids, argues against this longestablished theory.Using a double-checking liquid chromatography ESI-Q-TOF mass spectrometry routine, we traced the origin of colored eggs to their non-avian dinosaur ancestors by providing the first record of the avian eggshell pigments protoporphyrin and biliverdin in the eggshells of Late Cretaceous oviraptorid dinosaurs.The eggshell parataxon Macroolithus yaotunensis can be assigned to the oviraptor Heyuannia huangi based on exceptionally preserved, late developmental stage embryo remains.The analyzed eggshells are from three Late Cretaceous fluvial deposits ranging from eastern to southernmost China.Reevaluation of these taphonomic settings, and a consideration of patterns in the porosity of completely preserved eggs support an at least partially open nesting behavior for oviraptorosaurs.Such a nest arrangement corresponds with our reconstruction of blue-green eggs for oviraptors.According to the sexual signaling