Mapping the impact of levee failure on flood risks: A Toronto case study

Urban areas are frequently built along rivers and earthen levees are commonly used to protect areas from fluvial floods. Levees are designed to protect assets from flooding, however, they deteriorate over time. Maintenance checks are required to maintain their efficacy but even in good condition, a levee structure may fail during a flood, hence flood risk assessments in fluvial areas require an investigation of levee failures, e.g. by overtopping, erosion, or sliding. In this research, we investigate the failure probability due to backward erosion of an adapted levee in the Etobicoke Creek watershed, in Toronto, Canada. The study proposes an adapted levee as the residential area is often flooded. Backward erosion is the most probable and challenging failure mechanism for our case study based on the levee shape and soil type. For this probabilistic study, the levee was modelled using GeoStudio, which produces seepage analysis from geotechnical and hydrological parameters. The seepage analysis provides hydraulic gradients from which we determine the failure probability of backward erosion based on a critical hydraulic gradient value. To obtain the flood hazard, we use a steady flow hydraulic model (HEC-RAS) to simulate the 350-years return period flow through the River. We compare two backward failure scenarios: one with a levee breach and one without, to better understand how failure of the levee will impact flood risks, and therefore, highlighting the importance of on-going levee maintenance. To obtain flood risk maps, the flood hazard (i.e., flood extent) is combined with flood exposure. The flood exposure includes land-use type (residential, commercial, etc.) and demographic information. Flood hazard and exposure data are combined using ArcGIS. The flood hazard and exposure rasters are reclassified in a new scale to determine flood risk. We then overlay the rasters to determine the spatial distribution of flood risk for both scenarios. We compare the resulting flood risk maps and calculate the change in flood risks for the area protected by the levee. Accounting for potential failure of infrastructure in flood risk mapping results in more accurate risk estimations. We also demonstrate the positive impact of the levee.