Fixed Contributions Designs <i>vs</i>. Minimization of Global Coancestry to Control Inbreeding in Small Populations

Abstract Populations with small census sizes are at risk because of the loss of genetic variability and the increase of inbreeding and its harmful consequences. For situations with different numbers of males and females, several hierarchical designs have been proposed to control inbreeding through the fixation of individuals' contributions. An alternative method, based on the minimization of global coancestry, has been proposed to determine contributions as to yield of the lowest levels of inbreeding in the population. We use computer simulations to assess the relative efficiency of the different methods. The results show that minimizing the global coancestry leads to equal or lower levels of inbreeding in the short and medium term, although one of the hierarchical designs provides lower asymptotic inbreeding rates and, thus, less net inbreeding in the long term. We also investigate the performance of the alternative methods against departures from the ideal conditions, such as inbred or differentially related base individuals and random failures in the expected contributions. The method of minimization of global coancestry turns out to be more flexible and robust under these realistic situations.