Evolutionary dynamics of asexual hypermutators adapting to a novel environment

Abstract How microbes adapt to a novel environment is a central question in evolutionary biology. While adaptive evolution must be fueled by beneficial mutations, whether higher mutation rates facilitate the rate of adaptive evolution remains unclear. To address this question, we cultured Escherichia coli hypermutating populations, in which a defective methyl-directed mismatch repair pathway causes a 140-fold increase in single-nucleotide mutation rates. In parallel with wild-type E. coli , populations were cultured in tubes containing Luria-Bertani broth, a complex medium known to promote the evolution of subpopulation structure. After 900 days of evolution, in three transfer schemes with different population-size bottlenecks, hypermutators always exhibited similar levels of improved fitness as controls. Fluctuation tests revealed that the mutation rates of hypermutator lines converged evolutionarily on those of wild-type populations, which may have contributed to the absence of fitness differences. Further genome-sequence analysis revealed that, although hypermutator populations have higher rates of genomic evolution, this largely reflects the effects of genetic draft under strong linkage. Despite these linkage effects, the evolved populations exhibit parallelism in fixed mutations, including those potentially related to biofilm formation, transcription regulation, and mutation-rate evolution. Together, these results generally negate the presumed relationship between high mutation rates and high adaptive speed of evolution, providing insight into how clonal adaptation occurs in novel environments. Significance statement While mutations are critical source for the adaptation in a new environment, whether or not the elevated mutation rates can empirically lead to the elevated adaptation rates remains unclear, especially when the environment is more heterogenous. To answer this question, we evolved E. coli populations with different starting mutation rates in a complex medium for 900 days and then examined their fitness and genome profiles. In the populations that have a higher starting mutation rate, despite faster genome evolution, their fitness improvement is not significantly faster. Our results reveal that the effect of elevated mutation rates is only very limited, and the mutations accumulated in hypermutators are largely due to linkage effect.