Comparison of the myocardial effects of desflurane and isoflurane in healthy patients: assessment by continuous oesophageal aortic blood flow echo-Doppler

Experimentally, desflurane causes a moderate positive inotropic effect and a transient increase in arterial pressure with rapid increases in concentration compared with isoflurane. We used a continuous oesophageal aortic blood flow echo Doppler device to study the myocardial effects of equi-anaesthetic concentrations of isoflurane and desflurane in 32 healthy patients undergoing superficial surgery. After induction of anaesthesia with midazolam, etomidate and fentanyl general anaesthesia was maintained in 16 patients with 0.6% end-expired concentration of isoflurane and in 16 patients with 3% end expired concentration of desflurane. Isoflurane induced a rapid decrease in aortic blood flow (ABF) which remained almost stable whereas desflurane induced an early, moderate and transient increase in ABF (1 min after introduction of the halogenated agent, mean ABF was 107 (SD 3)% in the desflurane group vs 95 (9)% in isoflurane group compared with control values before introduction of the inhalation agent; P = 0.005), followed by a marked secondary decrease in ABF. The maximal decrease in ABF reached 71 (15)% of its initial value in the desflurane group compared with 80 (14)% in the isoflurane group (ns). Neither agent caused significant changes in other variables except for PE'CO2 which decreased in both groups. Continuous ABF echo-Doppler monitoring demonstrated an early transient positive inotropic effect of desflurane.